Nov 2, 2010

Beautiful But Fragile-Eastern Taiwan



Since I live in a city with smooth weather, it is quite difficult for me to imagine the condition of eastern Taiwan. However, it is easy for us to get the information about the region via the media and the Internet. Typhoon Megi struck Taiwan in October, 2010. The intense rain and winds led to the collapse of Su-Hua Highway. According to the thorough investigation, the major problem of eastern Taiwan must be the fragile geological structure. When we read a topographic chart of Taiwan, it is obvious that over half of the eastern lands are mountains. What is worse is that when it rains heavily, mud will run down the steep mountains, and cause the landslide.



In order to get a better understanding about the eastern side of Taiwan, I have done some online survey about people who have different points of view upon the development of this region. The politicians who voice for the people share the same opinion with the local residents, they approve of building Su-Hua Highway, “We have waited for twenty years. We just want to have a path that can bring us back to home safely.” said the dwellers. Nevertheless, when it comes to the decision maker (the governor), things become complicated. Though the governor would like to offer the local residents a secure way to home, there are still two difficulties for him to solve. One is the environmental appraisal; the other is the disapproving of scholars and environmental groups. For the latter one, their declaration is “The natural landscape should not be destroyed by artificial structure.”


I think that the reason why people call eastern Taiwan under-developed is that the Taiwan government tries hard to protect the natural resource there, so there are almost no large-sized buildings, or industrial park. If I were the next governor of Yi-Lan or Hualien County, the top priority of my service would be moving the villages which are in highly danger to a safe place. The lands of Yi-Lan and Hualien County are occupied by Central Mountains. When there is a typhoon coming, it may cause landslide, and the possibility of burying a village is very high. So, I think that moving the village is a necessary strategy to protect the local people in eastern Taiwan.








4 comments:

  1. Typhoon Megi did cause a major catastrophe in Taiwan especially for people who lived in and just traveled around Ilan and Hualien. I could barely read the news related to Typhoon Megi without knitting my brow in deep sorrow in the following days after the disaster happened. In fact, the Suhua Highway has long been prone to disaster, culminating with the rockslides on Oct. 21 that resulted in its collapse and heavy casualties.

    From that day on, the passage toward Hualien had been completely blocked. Therefore, thousands of angry protestors hailing from Hualien County revealed their resentment against the governors and urged the government to expedite the rebuilding process of the Suhua Highway. And the Suhua Highway passed environmental probe right after protests which broke the record as the fastest ever preliminary environmental evaluation.

    According to my observation, residents in Hualien used to be dogged by typhoon and earthquake. Just as you’ve mentioned, reasons why these poor consequences happened to residents in Hualien are because of the fragile geological structure and it’s where the Central Mountain Range located. For most of typhoons all invade from the eastern Taiwan and the height of Central Mountain Range avoids people in western Taiwan suffering from lots of disaster, we people like us who live in western Taiwan are able to lead a more comfortable life. However, people who grow up in eastern Taiwan won’t be pessimistic about their living environment. Instead, people who grow up in eastern Taiwan tend to be positive for they’re able to put up with all the uncontrollable things.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When it comes to casualties, there are a group of travels from China . They are victims of the collapse of Su-Hua Highway . When the relief operations are proceeding, it is no matter who is a Taiwanese, and who is a Chinese. The first priority is to rescue those who are in danger.

      Since eastern Taiwan is at the intersection of Eurasian Plate and Philippine Sea Plate, there are plenty of earthquakes. Typhoons which hit Taiwan usually come from the Pacific Ocean, which is at the right side of Taiwan . When the two elements combined, it may cause serious disaster.

      Based on our task, here are some questions for you: “If you were the next governor of Yi-Lan or Hualien County , what would be the top priority of your service? How is your plan going to help both the local people and Taiwan ?” From the two questions, I would like to know what your idea is.

      Delete
  2. If I were the next governor of Yi-Lan or Hualien County, I will definitely devote myself to seeding up the completion of Suhua Highway for we should never block their way home. As for the policy of helping the local people in Yi-Lan or Hualien, helping them to reconstruct their homes attacked by the great rainfall and landslide should be the governor’s duty. Just as you’ve mentioned before, I’ll ask people who live in highly dangerous places to move in safer residences temporarily. And I believe that there should be standard which has been set for subsidizing the victims. Honestly speaking, I don’t quite get the idea about what do you mean by helping Taiwan? However, I do have some suggestions for Taiwan government when dealing with the requests that made by Chinese government.

    Recently, the Chinese authorities ask Taiwan government to set tombstone for Chinese victims who were dead from the unpredictable accident. Actually, I don’t regard it as Taiwan government’s responsibility. It doesn’t mean that I’m merciless or I disrespect those victims. It’s because that it can be a controversial issue for both Taiwanese and Chinese people. Moreover, I totally agree with Premier Wu Den-yih’s statement which is that “Government compensation for Chinese victims of accidents in Taiwan must be based on reciprocity, because the issue is also related to the rights of Taiwanese people who meet with accidents in China.”

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Suhua Highway is indeed an important project that the government should start right away. Without this path, it is hard for the local residents in eastern Taiwan get back to their home.

      A couple days ago, it was reported that whether the folks of Chinese victims could seek a state compensation. It is another issue for us to think about.

      Delete